Is it not correct to say “I have the brown eyes” instead of “I have brown eyes”, and why?












3














I encountered the following sentence in a Duolingo French course and there are no other sentences:




I have brown eyes.




However, I was told that "I have the brown eyes." is not correct here. I don't understand the reason, so I would like to ask, why is the use of a definite article (the) not correct in this sentence?










share|improve this question





























    3














    I encountered the following sentence in a Duolingo French course and there are no other sentences:




    I have brown eyes.




    However, I was told that "I have the brown eyes." is not correct here. I don't understand the reason, so I would like to ask, why is the use of a definite article (the) not correct in this sentence?










    share|improve this question



























      3












      3








      3







      I encountered the following sentence in a Duolingo French course and there are no other sentences:




      I have brown eyes.




      However, I was told that "I have the brown eyes." is not correct here. I don't understand the reason, so I would like to ask, why is the use of a definite article (the) not correct in this sentence?










      share|improve this question















      I encountered the following sentence in a Duolingo French course and there are no other sentences:




      I have brown eyes.




      However, I was told that "I have the brown eyes." is not correct here. I don't understand the reason, so I would like to ask, why is the use of a definite article (the) not correct in this sentence?







      articles definite-article






      share|improve this question















      share|improve this question













      share|improve this question




      share|improve this question








      edited 49 mins ago









      ColleenV

      10.4k53159




      10.4k53159










      asked 2 hours ago









      BlaszardBlaszard

      2774517




      2774517






















          5 Answers
          5






          active

          oldest

          votes


















          5














          Eyes is a "plural count noun" and in this case we are talking about your eyes generally, rather than specifically. As a result, you can omit the the.



          See Rule #3 here:




          All things or things in general: Use no article with plural count
          nouns or any noncount nouns used to mean all or in general.




          In the case of your other example:




          I have the brown eyes




          If you were talking about a pair of glass eyeballs, that could be a correct sentence, but it's referring to a specific pair of eyes, rather than a general fact about yourself.



          Similarly, we say




          I am tall




          and not




          I have the height




          And




          I am hungry




          and not




          I have the hunger







          share|improve this answer








          New contributor




          Mako212 is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
          Check out our Code of Conduct.














          • 1




            Thanks. I found that my answer was wrong since the sentence talks about the generality. But in English, is there a case where "the" is used to express the generality?
            – Blaszard
            1 hour ago










          • @Blaszard If the group is large enough, it ends up sounding general even though it actually isn't. For example, 'the people' refers to the people of a specific place, but if that place is an entire country then the phrase sounds extremely general.
            – otah007
            32 mins ago










          • For example : We've lost the boxes of eyes for assembling the dragon statues - has anyone seen them?. I have the brown eyes, but I haven't seen the box of blue ones.
            – J...
            25 mins ago



















          5














          In certain contexts, the following is grammatical and idiomatic:




          I have the brown eyes.




          For example, if you're showing to someone a photograph of yourself as a child, and in the photo you are in the company of several children all about the same age as yourself, you might say




          I have the blue eyes.



          I have the bloody cheek.



          I have the hat on.




          to refer to the thing as a distinguishing feature. The statements above could be paraphrased as follows:



          I am the one whose eyes are blue.



          I am the one whose cheek is bloody



          I am the one who is wearing a hat.



          In the context of the photo, the feature is enough to single you out. There is only one instance of the feature in the photo.






          share|improve this answer































            2














            From a comment, it appears that you're coming from a French background, so I'll answer in that context.



            English article usage is similar in many ways to French usage, but not identical. One key difference is that in English we do not always use the definite article (or any article) when describing general concepts, or classes or categories.



            I always have a glass of milk with dinner because I like milk not ...because I like the milk. The milk would refer only to a specific kind of milk, not milk in general.



            Patience is a virtue not the patience is a virtue. Again, the patience would only refer to a specific kind of patience, such as you have the patience of a saint.



            I have brown hair not I have the brown hair. Same as above.



            There are cases when you can describe a general concept or class with either no article and plural, or definite article and singular. For instance:



            French people love good wine or The French people love good wine



            Lions are apex predators or The lion is an apex predator






            share|improve this answer





















            • I think your initial French point is extremely relevant. I wouldn't say I'm exactly fluent in French, but so far as I know it's tu as les yeux bleus, whereas Anglophones would never include an article there except in unusual / contrived contexts.
              – FumbleFingers
              1 hour ago



















            0














            'The' here would suggest that you have special kind of brown eyes.and Many people can have brown eyes which doesn't make having brown eyes unique. For ex-The sun-it means there is only one sun(well in our solar system)
            Hence if we say The brown eyes-it means there is only one pair of this kind of eyes.
            Another example-He is the man who killed her.It means there is only one special definite single person who killed her.






            share|improve this answer































              0














              There is no plural indefinite article in English, and this is a situation that would take an indefinite article.




              I have a large nose.



              I have small ears.



              I have ten fingers.



              I have a broken leg.




              Why the indefinite article? Here's the OED definition of a:




              Used in an indefinite noun phrase referring to something not specifically identified (and, frequently, mentioned for the first time) but treated as one of a class: one, some, any (the oneness, or indefiniteness, being implied rather than asserted).




              Emphasis mine. Roughly speaking, there are lots of large noses in the world, and the speaker in my first example is stating that they have one of them.



              In certain contexts, the definite article might be appropriate, as Tᴚoɯɐuo mentions: when the characteristic being referred to is the only one in the set of people under discussion, such as when looking at photograph, or identifying a person in a room.




              [Looking at a photograph] Q: Which are you? A: I'm the one with the large nose.




              This only works because the answerer is the only person in the photograph with a large nose.



              What if the photograph had several people with large noses, and several people with red hats, but the answerer was the only person with both? Indefinite articles.




              A: I'm the one with a large nose and a red hat.




              And if these were plural, we would use the plural indefinite if it existed, but since it does not, we use nothing:




              A: I'm the one with a large nose and brown eyes.







              share|improve this answer





















                Your Answer








                StackExchange.ready(function() {
                var channelOptions = {
                tags: "".split(" "),
                id: "481"
                };
                initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

                StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
                // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
                if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
                StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
                createEditor();
                });
                }
                else {
                createEditor();
                }
                });

                function createEditor() {
                StackExchange.prepareEditor({
                heartbeatType: 'answer',
                autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
                convertImagesToLinks: false,
                noModals: true,
                showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
                reputationToPostImages: null,
                bindNavPrevention: true,
                postfix: "",
                imageUploader: {
                brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
                contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
                allowUrls: true
                },
                noCode: true, onDemand: true,
                discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
                ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
                });


                }
                });














                draft saved

                draft discarded


















                StackExchange.ready(
                function () {
                StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fell.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f192152%2fis-it-not-correct-to-say-i-have-the-brown-eyes-instead-of-i-have-brown-eyes%23new-answer', 'question_page');
                }
                );

                Post as a guest















                Required, but never shown

























                5 Answers
                5






                active

                oldest

                votes








                5 Answers
                5






                active

                oldest

                votes









                active

                oldest

                votes






                active

                oldest

                votes









                5














                Eyes is a "plural count noun" and in this case we are talking about your eyes generally, rather than specifically. As a result, you can omit the the.



                See Rule #3 here:




                All things or things in general: Use no article with plural count
                nouns or any noncount nouns used to mean all or in general.




                In the case of your other example:




                I have the brown eyes




                If you were talking about a pair of glass eyeballs, that could be a correct sentence, but it's referring to a specific pair of eyes, rather than a general fact about yourself.



                Similarly, we say




                I am tall




                and not




                I have the height




                And




                I am hungry




                and not




                I have the hunger







                share|improve this answer








                New contributor




                Mako212 is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                Check out our Code of Conduct.














                • 1




                  Thanks. I found that my answer was wrong since the sentence talks about the generality. But in English, is there a case where "the" is used to express the generality?
                  – Blaszard
                  1 hour ago










                • @Blaszard If the group is large enough, it ends up sounding general even though it actually isn't. For example, 'the people' refers to the people of a specific place, but if that place is an entire country then the phrase sounds extremely general.
                  – otah007
                  32 mins ago










                • For example : We've lost the boxes of eyes for assembling the dragon statues - has anyone seen them?. I have the brown eyes, but I haven't seen the box of blue ones.
                  – J...
                  25 mins ago
















                5














                Eyes is a "plural count noun" and in this case we are talking about your eyes generally, rather than specifically. As a result, you can omit the the.



                See Rule #3 here:




                All things or things in general: Use no article with plural count
                nouns or any noncount nouns used to mean all or in general.




                In the case of your other example:




                I have the brown eyes




                If you were talking about a pair of glass eyeballs, that could be a correct sentence, but it's referring to a specific pair of eyes, rather than a general fact about yourself.



                Similarly, we say




                I am tall




                and not




                I have the height




                And




                I am hungry




                and not




                I have the hunger







                share|improve this answer








                New contributor




                Mako212 is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                Check out our Code of Conduct.














                • 1




                  Thanks. I found that my answer was wrong since the sentence talks about the generality. But in English, is there a case where "the" is used to express the generality?
                  – Blaszard
                  1 hour ago










                • @Blaszard If the group is large enough, it ends up sounding general even though it actually isn't. For example, 'the people' refers to the people of a specific place, but if that place is an entire country then the phrase sounds extremely general.
                  – otah007
                  32 mins ago










                • For example : We've lost the boxes of eyes for assembling the dragon statues - has anyone seen them?. I have the brown eyes, but I haven't seen the box of blue ones.
                  – J...
                  25 mins ago














                5












                5








                5






                Eyes is a "plural count noun" and in this case we are talking about your eyes generally, rather than specifically. As a result, you can omit the the.



                See Rule #3 here:




                All things or things in general: Use no article with plural count
                nouns or any noncount nouns used to mean all or in general.




                In the case of your other example:




                I have the brown eyes




                If you were talking about a pair of glass eyeballs, that could be a correct sentence, but it's referring to a specific pair of eyes, rather than a general fact about yourself.



                Similarly, we say




                I am tall




                and not




                I have the height




                And




                I am hungry




                and not




                I have the hunger







                share|improve this answer








                New contributor




                Mako212 is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                Check out our Code of Conduct.









                Eyes is a "plural count noun" and in this case we are talking about your eyes generally, rather than specifically. As a result, you can omit the the.



                See Rule #3 here:




                All things or things in general: Use no article with plural count
                nouns or any noncount nouns used to mean all or in general.




                In the case of your other example:




                I have the brown eyes




                If you were talking about a pair of glass eyeballs, that could be a correct sentence, but it's referring to a specific pair of eyes, rather than a general fact about yourself.



                Similarly, we say




                I am tall




                and not




                I have the height




                And




                I am hungry




                and not




                I have the hunger








                share|improve this answer








                New contributor




                Mako212 is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                Check out our Code of Conduct.









                share|improve this answer



                share|improve this answer






                New contributor




                Mako212 is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                Check out our Code of Conduct.









                answered 1 hour ago









                Mako212Mako212

                1662




                1662




                New contributor




                Mako212 is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                Check out our Code of Conduct.





                New contributor





                Mako212 is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                Check out our Code of Conduct.






                Mako212 is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                Check out our Code of Conduct.








                • 1




                  Thanks. I found that my answer was wrong since the sentence talks about the generality. But in English, is there a case where "the" is used to express the generality?
                  – Blaszard
                  1 hour ago










                • @Blaszard If the group is large enough, it ends up sounding general even though it actually isn't. For example, 'the people' refers to the people of a specific place, but if that place is an entire country then the phrase sounds extremely general.
                  – otah007
                  32 mins ago










                • For example : We've lost the boxes of eyes for assembling the dragon statues - has anyone seen them?. I have the brown eyes, but I haven't seen the box of blue ones.
                  – J...
                  25 mins ago














                • 1




                  Thanks. I found that my answer was wrong since the sentence talks about the generality. But in English, is there a case where "the" is used to express the generality?
                  – Blaszard
                  1 hour ago










                • @Blaszard If the group is large enough, it ends up sounding general even though it actually isn't. For example, 'the people' refers to the people of a specific place, but if that place is an entire country then the phrase sounds extremely general.
                  – otah007
                  32 mins ago










                • For example : We've lost the boxes of eyes for assembling the dragon statues - has anyone seen them?. I have the brown eyes, but I haven't seen the box of blue ones.
                  – J...
                  25 mins ago








                1




                1




                Thanks. I found that my answer was wrong since the sentence talks about the generality. But in English, is there a case where "the" is used to express the generality?
                – Blaszard
                1 hour ago




                Thanks. I found that my answer was wrong since the sentence talks about the generality. But in English, is there a case where "the" is used to express the generality?
                – Blaszard
                1 hour ago












                @Blaszard If the group is large enough, it ends up sounding general even though it actually isn't. For example, 'the people' refers to the people of a specific place, but if that place is an entire country then the phrase sounds extremely general.
                – otah007
                32 mins ago




                @Blaszard If the group is large enough, it ends up sounding general even though it actually isn't. For example, 'the people' refers to the people of a specific place, but if that place is an entire country then the phrase sounds extremely general.
                – otah007
                32 mins ago












                For example : We've lost the boxes of eyes for assembling the dragon statues - has anyone seen them?. I have the brown eyes, but I haven't seen the box of blue ones.
                – J...
                25 mins ago




                For example : We've lost the boxes of eyes for assembling the dragon statues - has anyone seen them?. I have the brown eyes, but I haven't seen the box of blue ones.
                – J...
                25 mins ago













                5














                In certain contexts, the following is grammatical and idiomatic:




                I have the brown eyes.




                For example, if you're showing to someone a photograph of yourself as a child, and in the photo you are in the company of several children all about the same age as yourself, you might say




                I have the blue eyes.



                I have the bloody cheek.



                I have the hat on.




                to refer to the thing as a distinguishing feature. The statements above could be paraphrased as follows:



                I am the one whose eyes are blue.



                I am the one whose cheek is bloody



                I am the one who is wearing a hat.



                In the context of the photo, the feature is enough to single you out. There is only one instance of the feature in the photo.






                share|improve this answer




























                  5














                  In certain contexts, the following is grammatical and idiomatic:




                  I have the brown eyes.




                  For example, if you're showing to someone a photograph of yourself as a child, and in the photo you are in the company of several children all about the same age as yourself, you might say




                  I have the blue eyes.



                  I have the bloody cheek.



                  I have the hat on.




                  to refer to the thing as a distinguishing feature. The statements above could be paraphrased as follows:



                  I am the one whose eyes are blue.



                  I am the one whose cheek is bloody



                  I am the one who is wearing a hat.



                  In the context of the photo, the feature is enough to single you out. There is only one instance of the feature in the photo.






                  share|improve this answer


























                    5












                    5








                    5






                    In certain contexts, the following is grammatical and idiomatic:




                    I have the brown eyes.




                    For example, if you're showing to someone a photograph of yourself as a child, and in the photo you are in the company of several children all about the same age as yourself, you might say




                    I have the blue eyes.



                    I have the bloody cheek.



                    I have the hat on.




                    to refer to the thing as a distinguishing feature. The statements above could be paraphrased as follows:



                    I am the one whose eyes are blue.



                    I am the one whose cheek is bloody



                    I am the one who is wearing a hat.



                    In the context of the photo, the feature is enough to single you out. There is only one instance of the feature in the photo.






                    share|improve this answer














                    In certain contexts, the following is grammatical and idiomatic:




                    I have the brown eyes.




                    For example, if you're showing to someone a photograph of yourself as a child, and in the photo you are in the company of several children all about the same age as yourself, you might say




                    I have the blue eyes.



                    I have the bloody cheek.



                    I have the hat on.




                    to refer to the thing as a distinguishing feature. The statements above could be paraphrased as follows:



                    I am the one whose eyes are blue.



                    I am the one whose cheek is bloody



                    I am the one who is wearing a hat.



                    In the context of the photo, the feature is enough to single you out. There is only one instance of the feature in the photo.







                    share|improve this answer














                    share|improve this answer



                    share|improve this answer








                    edited 1 hour ago

























                    answered 1 hour ago









                    TᴚoɯɐuoTᴚoɯɐuo

                    109k683176




                    109k683176























                        2














                        From a comment, it appears that you're coming from a French background, so I'll answer in that context.



                        English article usage is similar in many ways to French usage, but not identical. One key difference is that in English we do not always use the definite article (or any article) when describing general concepts, or classes or categories.



                        I always have a glass of milk with dinner because I like milk not ...because I like the milk. The milk would refer only to a specific kind of milk, not milk in general.



                        Patience is a virtue not the patience is a virtue. Again, the patience would only refer to a specific kind of patience, such as you have the patience of a saint.



                        I have brown hair not I have the brown hair. Same as above.



                        There are cases when you can describe a general concept or class with either no article and plural, or definite article and singular. For instance:



                        French people love good wine or The French people love good wine



                        Lions are apex predators or The lion is an apex predator






                        share|improve this answer





















                        • I think your initial French point is extremely relevant. I wouldn't say I'm exactly fluent in French, but so far as I know it's tu as les yeux bleus, whereas Anglophones would never include an article there except in unusual / contrived contexts.
                          – FumbleFingers
                          1 hour ago
















                        2














                        From a comment, it appears that you're coming from a French background, so I'll answer in that context.



                        English article usage is similar in many ways to French usage, but not identical. One key difference is that in English we do not always use the definite article (or any article) when describing general concepts, or classes or categories.



                        I always have a glass of milk with dinner because I like milk not ...because I like the milk. The milk would refer only to a specific kind of milk, not milk in general.



                        Patience is a virtue not the patience is a virtue. Again, the patience would only refer to a specific kind of patience, such as you have the patience of a saint.



                        I have brown hair not I have the brown hair. Same as above.



                        There are cases when you can describe a general concept or class with either no article and plural, or definite article and singular. For instance:



                        French people love good wine or The French people love good wine



                        Lions are apex predators or The lion is an apex predator






                        share|improve this answer





















                        • I think your initial French point is extremely relevant. I wouldn't say I'm exactly fluent in French, but so far as I know it's tu as les yeux bleus, whereas Anglophones would never include an article there except in unusual / contrived contexts.
                          – FumbleFingers
                          1 hour ago














                        2












                        2








                        2






                        From a comment, it appears that you're coming from a French background, so I'll answer in that context.



                        English article usage is similar in many ways to French usage, but not identical. One key difference is that in English we do not always use the definite article (or any article) when describing general concepts, or classes or categories.



                        I always have a glass of milk with dinner because I like milk not ...because I like the milk. The milk would refer only to a specific kind of milk, not milk in general.



                        Patience is a virtue not the patience is a virtue. Again, the patience would only refer to a specific kind of patience, such as you have the patience of a saint.



                        I have brown hair not I have the brown hair. Same as above.



                        There are cases when you can describe a general concept or class with either no article and plural, or definite article and singular. For instance:



                        French people love good wine or The French people love good wine



                        Lions are apex predators or The lion is an apex predator






                        share|improve this answer












                        From a comment, it appears that you're coming from a French background, so I'll answer in that context.



                        English article usage is similar in many ways to French usage, but not identical. One key difference is that in English we do not always use the definite article (or any article) when describing general concepts, or classes or categories.



                        I always have a glass of milk with dinner because I like milk not ...because I like the milk. The milk would refer only to a specific kind of milk, not milk in general.



                        Patience is a virtue not the patience is a virtue. Again, the patience would only refer to a specific kind of patience, such as you have the patience of a saint.



                        I have brown hair not I have the brown hair. Same as above.



                        There are cases when you can describe a general concept or class with either no article and plural, or definite article and singular. For instance:



                        French people love good wine or The French people love good wine



                        Lions are apex predators or The lion is an apex predator







                        share|improve this answer












                        share|improve this answer



                        share|improve this answer










                        answered 1 hour ago









                        JuhaszJuhasz

                        9924




                        9924












                        • I think your initial French point is extremely relevant. I wouldn't say I'm exactly fluent in French, but so far as I know it's tu as les yeux bleus, whereas Anglophones would never include an article there except in unusual / contrived contexts.
                          – FumbleFingers
                          1 hour ago


















                        • I think your initial French point is extremely relevant. I wouldn't say I'm exactly fluent in French, but so far as I know it's tu as les yeux bleus, whereas Anglophones would never include an article there except in unusual / contrived contexts.
                          – FumbleFingers
                          1 hour ago
















                        I think your initial French point is extremely relevant. I wouldn't say I'm exactly fluent in French, but so far as I know it's tu as les yeux bleus, whereas Anglophones would never include an article there except in unusual / contrived contexts.
                        – FumbleFingers
                        1 hour ago




                        I think your initial French point is extremely relevant. I wouldn't say I'm exactly fluent in French, but so far as I know it's tu as les yeux bleus, whereas Anglophones would never include an article there except in unusual / contrived contexts.
                        – FumbleFingers
                        1 hour ago











                        0














                        'The' here would suggest that you have special kind of brown eyes.and Many people can have brown eyes which doesn't make having brown eyes unique. For ex-The sun-it means there is only one sun(well in our solar system)
                        Hence if we say The brown eyes-it means there is only one pair of this kind of eyes.
                        Another example-He is the man who killed her.It means there is only one special definite single person who killed her.






                        share|improve this answer




























                          0














                          'The' here would suggest that you have special kind of brown eyes.and Many people can have brown eyes which doesn't make having brown eyes unique. For ex-The sun-it means there is only one sun(well in our solar system)
                          Hence if we say The brown eyes-it means there is only one pair of this kind of eyes.
                          Another example-He is the man who killed her.It means there is only one special definite single person who killed her.






                          share|improve this answer


























                            0












                            0








                            0






                            'The' here would suggest that you have special kind of brown eyes.and Many people can have brown eyes which doesn't make having brown eyes unique. For ex-The sun-it means there is only one sun(well in our solar system)
                            Hence if we say The brown eyes-it means there is only one pair of this kind of eyes.
                            Another example-He is the man who killed her.It means there is only one special definite single person who killed her.






                            share|improve this answer














                            'The' here would suggest that you have special kind of brown eyes.and Many people can have brown eyes which doesn't make having brown eyes unique. For ex-The sun-it means there is only one sun(well in our solar system)
                            Hence if we say The brown eyes-it means there is only one pair of this kind of eyes.
                            Another example-He is the man who killed her.It means there is only one special definite single person who killed her.







                            share|improve this answer














                            share|improve this answer



                            share|improve this answer








                            edited 1 hour ago

























                            answered 1 hour ago









                            Manish Kumar BalayanManish Kumar Balayan

                            236




                            236























                                0














                                There is no plural indefinite article in English, and this is a situation that would take an indefinite article.




                                I have a large nose.



                                I have small ears.



                                I have ten fingers.



                                I have a broken leg.




                                Why the indefinite article? Here's the OED definition of a:




                                Used in an indefinite noun phrase referring to something not specifically identified (and, frequently, mentioned for the first time) but treated as one of a class: one, some, any (the oneness, or indefiniteness, being implied rather than asserted).




                                Emphasis mine. Roughly speaking, there are lots of large noses in the world, and the speaker in my first example is stating that they have one of them.



                                In certain contexts, the definite article might be appropriate, as Tᴚoɯɐuo mentions: when the characteristic being referred to is the only one in the set of people under discussion, such as when looking at photograph, or identifying a person in a room.




                                [Looking at a photograph] Q: Which are you? A: I'm the one with the large nose.




                                This only works because the answerer is the only person in the photograph with a large nose.



                                What if the photograph had several people with large noses, and several people with red hats, but the answerer was the only person with both? Indefinite articles.




                                A: I'm the one with a large nose and a red hat.




                                And if these were plural, we would use the plural indefinite if it existed, but since it does not, we use nothing:




                                A: I'm the one with a large nose and brown eyes.







                                share|improve this answer


























                                  0














                                  There is no plural indefinite article in English, and this is a situation that would take an indefinite article.




                                  I have a large nose.



                                  I have small ears.



                                  I have ten fingers.



                                  I have a broken leg.




                                  Why the indefinite article? Here's the OED definition of a:




                                  Used in an indefinite noun phrase referring to something not specifically identified (and, frequently, mentioned for the first time) but treated as one of a class: one, some, any (the oneness, or indefiniteness, being implied rather than asserted).




                                  Emphasis mine. Roughly speaking, there are lots of large noses in the world, and the speaker in my first example is stating that they have one of them.



                                  In certain contexts, the definite article might be appropriate, as Tᴚoɯɐuo mentions: when the characteristic being referred to is the only one in the set of people under discussion, such as when looking at photograph, or identifying a person in a room.




                                  [Looking at a photograph] Q: Which are you? A: I'm the one with the large nose.




                                  This only works because the answerer is the only person in the photograph with a large nose.



                                  What if the photograph had several people with large noses, and several people with red hats, but the answerer was the only person with both? Indefinite articles.




                                  A: I'm the one with a large nose and a red hat.




                                  And if these were plural, we would use the plural indefinite if it existed, but since it does not, we use nothing:




                                  A: I'm the one with a large nose and brown eyes.







                                  share|improve this answer
























                                    0












                                    0








                                    0






                                    There is no plural indefinite article in English, and this is a situation that would take an indefinite article.




                                    I have a large nose.



                                    I have small ears.



                                    I have ten fingers.



                                    I have a broken leg.




                                    Why the indefinite article? Here's the OED definition of a:




                                    Used in an indefinite noun phrase referring to something not specifically identified (and, frequently, mentioned for the first time) but treated as one of a class: one, some, any (the oneness, or indefiniteness, being implied rather than asserted).




                                    Emphasis mine. Roughly speaking, there are lots of large noses in the world, and the speaker in my first example is stating that they have one of them.



                                    In certain contexts, the definite article might be appropriate, as Tᴚoɯɐuo mentions: when the characteristic being referred to is the only one in the set of people under discussion, such as when looking at photograph, or identifying a person in a room.




                                    [Looking at a photograph] Q: Which are you? A: I'm the one with the large nose.




                                    This only works because the answerer is the only person in the photograph with a large nose.



                                    What if the photograph had several people with large noses, and several people with red hats, but the answerer was the only person with both? Indefinite articles.




                                    A: I'm the one with a large nose and a red hat.




                                    And if these were plural, we would use the plural indefinite if it existed, but since it does not, we use nothing:




                                    A: I'm the one with a large nose and brown eyes.







                                    share|improve this answer












                                    There is no plural indefinite article in English, and this is a situation that would take an indefinite article.




                                    I have a large nose.



                                    I have small ears.



                                    I have ten fingers.



                                    I have a broken leg.




                                    Why the indefinite article? Here's the OED definition of a:




                                    Used in an indefinite noun phrase referring to something not specifically identified (and, frequently, mentioned for the first time) but treated as one of a class: one, some, any (the oneness, or indefiniteness, being implied rather than asserted).




                                    Emphasis mine. Roughly speaking, there are lots of large noses in the world, and the speaker in my first example is stating that they have one of them.



                                    In certain contexts, the definite article might be appropriate, as Tᴚoɯɐuo mentions: when the characteristic being referred to is the only one in the set of people under discussion, such as when looking at photograph, or identifying a person in a room.




                                    [Looking at a photograph] Q: Which are you? A: I'm the one with the large nose.




                                    This only works because the answerer is the only person in the photograph with a large nose.



                                    What if the photograph had several people with large noses, and several people with red hats, but the answerer was the only person with both? Indefinite articles.




                                    A: I'm the one with a large nose and a red hat.




                                    And if these were plural, we would use the plural indefinite if it existed, but since it does not, we use nothing:




                                    A: I'm the one with a large nose and brown eyes.








                                    share|improve this answer












                                    share|improve this answer



                                    share|improve this answer










                                    answered 17 mins ago









                                    Matthew WMatthew W

                                    1,838619




                                    1,838619






























                                        draft saved

                                        draft discarded




















































                                        Thanks for contributing an answer to English Language Learners Stack Exchange!


                                        • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

                                        But avoid



                                        • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

                                        • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


                                        To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.





                                        Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.


                                        Please pay close attention to the following guidance:


                                        • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

                                        But avoid



                                        • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

                                        • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


                                        To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




                                        draft saved


                                        draft discarded














                                        StackExchange.ready(
                                        function () {
                                        StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fell.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f192152%2fis-it-not-correct-to-say-i-have-the-brown-eyes-instead-of-i-have-brown-eyes%23new-answer', 'question_page');
                                        }
                                        );

                                        Post as a guest















                                        Required, but never shown





















































                                        Required, but never shown














                                        Required, but never shown












                                        Required, but never shown







                                        Required, but never shown

































                                        Required, but never shown














                                        Required, but never shown












                                        Required, but never shown







                                        Required, but never shown







                                        Popular posts from this blog

                                        CARDNET

                                        Boot-repair Failure: Unable to locate package grub-common:i386

                                        濃尾地震