Yrurtj

I wrote a small program shown below that counts how many times an infinite recursive loop will go before causing a StackOverflow error.

public class Testing {

    static void p(int i) {

        System.out.println("hello" + i);

        i++;

        p(i);

    }

    public static void main(String args) {

        p(1);

    }

}

The thing is, it errors on a different number each time, normally between 8000 and 9000. Can anyone explain why this happens?

EDIT: I'm using the Eclipse IDE, haven't tested it with other IDE's or the command line.

The JVM specs very nicely explain its behavior related to stack;

Each Java Virtual Machine thread has a private Java Virtual Machine
stack, created at the same time as the thread. A Java Virtual Machine
stack stores frames (§2.6). A Java Virtual Machine stack is analogous
to the stack of a conventional language such as C: it holds local
variables and partial results, and plays a part in method invocation
and return. Because the Java Virtual Machine stack is never
manipulated directly except to push and pop frames, frames may be heap
allocated. The memory for a Java Virtual Machine stack does not need
to be contiguous.

In the First Edition of The Java® Virtual Machine Specification, the
Java Virtual Machine stack was known as the Java stack.

This specification permits Java Virtual Machine stacks either to be of
a fixed size or to dynamically expand and contract as required by the
computation. If the Java Virtual Machine stacks are of a fixed size,
the size of each Java Virtual Machine stack may be chosen
independently when that stack is created.

A Java Virtual Machine implementation may provide the programmer or
the user control over the initial size of Java Virtual Machine stacks,
as well as, in the case of dynamically expanding or contracting Java
Virtual Machine stacks, control over the maximum and minimum sizes.

The following exceptional conditions are associated with Java Virtual
Machine stacks:

If the computation in a thread requires a larger Java Virtual Machine
stack than is permitted, the Java Virtual Machine throws a
StackOverflowError.

If Java Virtual Machine stacks can be dynamically expanded, and
expansion is attempted but insufficient memory can be made available
to effect the expansion, or if insufficient memory can be made
available to create the initial Java Virtual Machine stack for a new
thread, the Java Virtual Machine throws an OutOfMemoryError.

An important point from this excerpt as far as your question is concerned:

• This specification permits Java Virtual Machine stacks either to be of a fixed size or to dynamically expand and contract as required by the computation.

Since you are not providing a stack size, JVM tries to dynamically expand the stack size as the function gets called recursively needing more stack memory. In each run, it may find different amount of dynamic memory for its stack depending on the availability of memory on your computer at that point of run. This is the reason you see a different value for the number of iterations it takes before throwing the SO error. If you configure (using Xss<size> JVM parameter) a smaller stack size to your program, you should see mostly identical number of recursions before the SO error.

Might be related to how much real memory the computer can allocate to the program, while other programs and process are running in the computer

StackOverflowError is a error. As a error, is related to the JVM (a error is not a Exception!).

This error occurs when your stack (or method execution stack) collides with your heap size (JVM's memory).

The size of JVM's heap can be defined, but from your stack no.

So as others have pointed out you may have to look into what jvm is beings used and from there it might also be a good exercise to know what garbage collector (how often gc is being called ) is being used as this may give you a deeper understanding not only about stack overflow error but how generally Java works. And if really keen you could implement your own small JVM and may be with a better scheme.

StackOverflowError is thrown, when stack (part of memory, where method execution stack is stored) collides with heap (memory, that allocates objects, primitives etc.). You cannot predict, when the error is thrown, because the size of stack can be dynamic unless specified by -Xss flag. That's why there is no fixed method execution depth, that causes StackOverflowError.