Why do some congregations only make noise at certain occasions of Haman?












3















Attended a Purim Seudah tonight at a Sephardic shul where most of the attendees are Israeli. They only made noise during three (maybe four?) times Haman's name was mentioned. I am aware of the teshuva saying "no noise", but can't find anything explaining "sometimes." Is there a soource for this concept?






sources-mekorot purim







share|improve this question









New contributor




Deborah Savage is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.





















  • Hi Deborah, and welcome to Mi Yodeya. As it currently stands your post is phrased as a statement rather than a question. Since this is specifically a question and answer site, your post might get closed if there is no clear question contained therein. To prevent this from possibly happening you can edit your post to make it into a clear question.

    – Alex
    3 hours ago






  • 1





    From memory, there are those who only make noise when there is an extension to the name, such as Haman HaAgagi. However, when the name is used alone there is no name.

    – sabbahillel
    3 hours ago






  • 1





    Maybe it's just a compromise to just do a few

    – Double AA♦
    3 hours ago











  • Thanks to both early responders. I edited to make the question clear and look forwarded to learning more!

    – Deborah Savage
    3 hours ago











  • I thought I read/heard last night that Sephardim only do it for the Haman in Shoshanat Ya'akov.

    – rosends
    3 hours ago
















3















Attended a Purim Seudah tonight at a Sephardic shul where most of the attendees are Israeli. They only made noise during three (maybe four?) times Haman's name was mentioned. I am aware of the teshuva saying "no noise", but can't find anything explaining "sometimes." Is there a soource for this concept?






sources-mekorot purim







share|improve this question









New contributor




Deborah Savage is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.





















  • Hi Deborah, and welcome to Mi Yodeya. As it currently stands your post is phrased as a statement rather than a question. Since this is specifically a question and answer site, your post might get closed if there is no clear question contained therein. To prevent this from possibly happening you can edit your post to make it into a clear question.

    – Alex
    3 hours ago






  • 1





    From memory, there are those who only make noise when there is an extension to the name, such as Haman HaAgagi. However, when the name is used alone there is no name.

    – sabbahillel
    3 hours ago






  • 1





    Maybe it's just a compromise to just do a few

    – Double AA♦
    3 hours ago











  • Thanks to both early responders. I edited to make the question clear and look forwarded to learning more!

    – Deborah Savage
    3 hours ago











  • I thought I read/heard last night that Sephardim only do it for the Haman in Shoshanat Ya'akov.

    – rosends
    3 hours ago














3












3








3








Attended a Purim Seudah tonight at a Sephardic shul where most of the attendees are Israeli. They only made noise during three (maybe four?) times Haman's name was mentioned. I am aware of the teshuva saying "no noise", but can't find anything explaining "sometimes." Is there a soource for this concept?






sources-mekorot purim







share|improve this question









New contributor




Deborah Savage is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.












Attended a Purim Seudah tonight at a Sephardic shul where most of the attendees are Israeli. They only made noise during three (maybe four?) times Haman's name was mentioned. I am aware of the teshuva saying "no noise", but can't find anything explaining "sometimes." Is there a soource for this concept?






sources-mekorot purim




sources-mekorot purim






share|improve this question









New contributor




Deborah Savage is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.











share|improve this question









New contributor




Deborah Savage is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.









share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited 1 hour ago









Rafael

562115




562115






New contributor




Deborah Savage is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.









asked 3 hours ago









Deborah SavageDeborah Savage

162




162




New contributor




Deborah Savage is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.





New contributor





Deborah Savage is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.






Deborah Savage is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.













  • Hi Deborah, and welcome to Mi Yodeya. As it currently stands your post is phrased as a statement rather than a question. Since this is specifically a question and answer site, your post might get closed if there is no clear question contained therein. To prevent this from possibly happening you can edit your post to make it into a clear question.

    – Alex
    3 hours ago






  • 1





    From memory, there are those who only make noise when there is an extension to the name, such as Haman HaAgagi. However, when the name is used alone there is no name.

    – sabbahillel
    3 hours ago






  • 1





    Maybe it's just a compromise to just do a few

    – Double AA♦
    3 hours ago











  • Thanks to both early responders. I edited to make the question clear and look forwarded to learning more!

    – Deborah Savage
    3 hours ago











  • I thought I read/heard last night that Sephardim only do it for the Haman in Shoshanat Ya'akov.

    – rosends
    3 hours ago



















  • Hi Deborah, and welcome to Mi Yodeya. As it currently stands your post is phrased as a statement rather than a question. Since this is specifically a question and answer site, your post might get closed if there is no clear question contained therein. To prevent this from possibly happening you can edit your post to make it into a clear question.

    – Alex
    3 hours ago






  • 1





    From memory, there are those who only make noise when there is an extension to the name, such as Haman HaAgagi. However, when the name is used alone there is no name.

    – sabbahillel
    3 hours ago






  • 1





    Maybe it's just a compromise to just do a few

    – Double AA♦
    3 hours ago











  • Thanks to both early responders. I edited to make the question clear and look forwarded to learning more!

    – Deborah Savage
    3 hours ago











  • I thought I read/heard last night that Sephardim only do it for the Haman in Shoshanat Ya'akov.

    – rosends
    3 hours ago

















Hi Deborah, and welcome to Mi Yodeya. As it currently stands your post is phrased as a statement rather than a question. Since this is specifically a question and answer site, your post might get closed if there is no clear question contained therein. To prevent this from possibly happening you can edit your post to make it into a clear question.

– Alex
3 hours ago





Hi Deborah, and welcome to Mi Yodeya. As it currently stands your post is phrased as a statement rather than a question. Since this is specifically a question and answer site, your post might get closed if there is no clear question contained therein. To prevent this from possibly happening you can edit your post to make it into a clear question.

– Alex
3 hours ago




1




1





From memory, there are those who only make noise when there is an extension to the name, such as Haman HaAgagi. However, when the name is used alone there is no name.

– sabbahillel
3 hours ago





From memory, there are those who only make noise when there is an extension to the name, such as Haman HaAgagi. However, when the name is used alone there is no name.

– sabbahillel
3 hours ago




1




1





Maybe it's just a compromise to just do a few

– Double AA♦
3 hours ago





Maybe it's just a compromise to just do a few

– Double AA♦
3 hours ago













Thanks to both early responders. I edited to make the question clear and look forwarded to learning more!

– Deborah Savage
3 hours ago





Thanks to both early responders. I edited to make the question clear and look forwarded to learning more!

– Deborah Savage
3 hours ago













I thought I read/heard last night that Sephardim only do it for the Haman in Shoshanat Ya'akov.

– rosends
3 hours ago





I thought I read/heard last night that Sephardim only do it for the Haman in Shoshanat Ya'akov.

– rosends
3 hours ago










1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes


















3














There are various customs about making noise when Haman is mentioned. Since you mention that it occured more than once, it sounds like the Chabad custom.




While most congregations allow banging each time Haman is mentioned,
others have the custom to do so only when his name is mentioned along
with an accolade, such as “Haman Ha’agagi” or “Haman
Hara”.38 Some only bang when hearing Haman’s name during
the segment which discusses the demise of Haman’s ten
sons.39 Yet others have the custom to do so only at the
first and last mention of Haman in the Megilla,40 or only
those references to Haman which discuss his downfall.41



38 Aruch Hashulchan 690:24, Sefer Haminhagim Chabad



39 Ketzot Hashulchan 690, Nahar Mitzrayim;Purim, Minhagim
of Worms 2:259



40 Ben Ish Chai;Tetzaveh



41 Emek Bracha Purim p.246







share|improve this answer































    1 Answer
    1






    active

    oldest

    votes








    1 Answer
    1






    active

    oldest

    votes









    active

    oldest

    votes






    active

    oldest

    votes









    3














    There are various customs about making noise when Haman is mentioned. Since you mention that it occured more than once, it sounds like the Chabad custom.




    While most congregations allow banging each time Haman is mentioned,
    others have the custom to do so only when his name is mentioned along
    with an accolade, such as “Haman Ha’agagi” or “Haman
    Hara”.38 Some only bang when hearing Haman’s name during
    the segment which discusses the demise of Haman’s ten
    sons.39 Yet others have the custom to do so only at the
    first and last mention of Haman in the Megilla,40 or only
    those references to Haman which discuss his downfall.41



    38 Aruch Hashulchan 690:24, Sefer Haminhagim Chabad



    39 Ketzot Hashulchan 690, Nahar Mitzrayim;Purim, Minhagim
    of Worms 2:259



    40 Ben Ish Chai;Tetzaveh



    41 Emek Bracha Purim p.246







    share|improve this answer




























      3














      There are various customs about making noise when Haman is mentioned. Since you mention that it occured more than once, it sounds like the Chabad custom.




      While most congregations allow banging each time Haman is mentioned,
      others have the custom to do so only when his name is mentioned along
      with an accolade, such as “Haman Ha’agagi” or “Haman
      Hara”.38 Some only bang when hearing Haman’s name during
      the segment which discusses the demise of Haman’s ten
      sons.39 Yet others have the custom to do so only at the
      first and last mention of Haman in the Megilla,40 or only
      those references to Haman which discuss his downfall.41



      38 Aruch Hashulchan 690:24, Sefer Haminhagim Chabad



      39 Ketzot Hashulchan 690, Nahar Mitzrayim;Purim, Minhagim
      of Worms 2:259



      40 Ben Ish Chai;Tetzaveh



      41 Emek Bracha Purim p.246







      share|improve this answer


























        3












        3








        3







        There are various customs about making noise when Haman is mentioned. Since you mention that it occured more than once, it sounds like the Chabad custom.




        While most congregations allow banging each time Haman is mentioned,
        others have the custom to do so only when his name is mentioned along
        with an accolade, such as “Haman Ha’agagi” or “Haman
        Hara”.38 Some only bang when hearing Haman’s name during
        the segment which discusses the demise of Haman’s ten
        sons.39 Yet others have the custom to do so only at the
        first and last mention of Haman in the Megilla,40 or only
        those references to Haman which discuss his downfall.41



        38 Aruch Hashulchan 690:24, Sefer Haminhagim Chabad



        39 Ketzot Hashulchan 690, Nahar Mitzrayim;Purim, Minhagim
        of Worms 2:259



        40 Ben Ish Chai;Tetzaveh



        41 Emek Bracha Purim p.246







        share|improve this answer













        There are various customs about making noise when Haman is mentioned. Since you mention that it occured more than once, it sounds like the Chabad custom.




        While most congregations allow banging each time Haman is mentioned,
        others have the custom to do so only when his name is mentioned along
        with an accolade, such as “Haman Ha’agagi” or “Haman
        Hara”.38 Some only bang when hearing Haman’s name during
        the segment which discusses the demise of Haman’s ten
        sons.39 Yet others have the custom to do so only at the
        first and last mention of Haman in the Megilla,40 or only
        those references to Haman which discuss his downfall.41



        38 Aruch Hashulchan 690:24, Sefer Haminhagim Chabad



        39 Ketzot Hashulchan 690, Nahar Mitzrayim;Purim, Minhagim
        of Worms 2:259



        40 Ben Ish Chai;Tetzaveh



        41 Emek Bracha Purim p.246








        share|improve this answer












        share|improve this answer



        share|improve this answer










        answered 3 hours ago









        sabbahillelsabbahillel

        34.6k23869




        34.6k23869















            -

            Popular posts from this blog

            CARDNET

            Image
            CARDNET は日本カードネットワークが運営するクレジット決済ネットワーク。日本カードネットワークの略称としてもCARDNETが使用されている。 事件・事故 2017年4月15日午前11時8分からクレジットカードの決済がしづらくなる障害が発生した。障害は同日午後5時18分に復旧した。原因は、複数あるCARDNETセンターの拠点のうち1つで、2重化してあるL3スイッチの片方が故障し、1系統にトラフィックが集中したことによる輻輳が発生したため。対処としては、故障したL3スイッチ交換とシステム再起動が行われた [1] 。 出典 ^ 金子寛人 ( 2017年4月17日 ). “CARDNETのクレジット決済に6時間強障害、原因はL3スイッチ故障”. 日経コンピュータ. 2018年10月18日 閲覧。 この項目は、コンピュータに関連した 書きかけの項目 です。この項目を加筆・訂正などしてくださる協力者を求めています（PJ:コンピュータ/P:コンピュータ）。 この項目は、経済に関連した 書きかけの項目 です。この項目を加筆・訂正などしてくださる協力者を求めています（ポータル 経済学、プロジェクト 経済）。 This page is only for reference, If you need detailed information, please check here
            Read more

            Boot-repair Failure: Unable to locate package grub-common:i386

            Image
            0 I am on a system dual-booting Windows and Debian (usually using the latter), and a recent Windows update appears to have wreaked havoc on the Debian boot system. I managed to boot Windows again, but not Linux. Following online suggestions, I created a Live USB of Ubuntu, and booted from that. Then I have installed and run the boot-repair utility. The utility instructs me to type several lines including sudo chroot "/mnt/boot-sav/sda6" apt-get purge -y grub*-common grub-common:i386 To which I receive the error E: Unable to locate package grub-common:i386 I am given to understand the issue may have to do with having UEFI vs BIOS (I believe I have UEFI), but do not understand this well. In any case I have subsequently run the boot-repair BootInfo Summary utility which created the following file h...
            Read more

            濃尾地震

            Image
            濃尾地震 『岐阜市街大地震之図』 歌川国利画 本震 発生日 1891年（明治24年）10月28日 発生時刻 6時38分50秒（JST） 震央 日本 岐阜県本巣郡西根尾村（現・本巣市） 北緯35度35分 東経136度20分（ 地図 ） 規模    マグニチュード（M）8.0 最大震度    震度7： 注1 福井県今立郡鯖江町、愛知県葉栗郡大田島村、東春日井郡勝川村 地震の種類 直下型地震 被害 死傷者数 死者7,273人、負傷者17,175人 注1：当時の震度階級では「激烈」 プロジェクト:地球科学 プロジェクト:災害 テンプレートを表示 濃尾地震 （のうびじしん）は、1891年（明治24年）10月28日に濃尾地方で発生した、日本史上最大の内陸地殻内地震。「 美濃・尾張地震 （みの・おわりじしん）」とも呼ばれている。辛卯の年に発生したことから 辛卯震災 と呼んでいる報告書もある。 目次 1 概要 1.1 震源断層 2 被害 3 各地の震度 4 前兆現象 5 報道 6 学術的な意義 7 地震防災 8 脚注 9 関連項目 10 外部リンク 概要 濃尾地震発生当時の根尾谷断層 濃尾地震を引き起こした根尾谷断層 写真中央を斜めに走る段差が根尾谷断層 濃尾地震は、1891年10月28日6時38分50秒に発生した。震源は、岐阜県本巣郡西根尾村（現・本巣市）、北緯35度35分、東経136度20分付近。河角廣 (1951) は岐阜市付近（北緯35.6度、東経136.6度）に震央を仮定し規模 M K = 7.0 を与え [1] 、マグニチュードは M = 8.4 に換算されているが、明治・大正期の地震については0.5程度大きく見積もられているとされる [2] 。また、震央距離と震度との関係など当時のデータから後にM8.0 [3] とも推定される。アメリカ地質調査所 (USGS) でも8.0としている [4] 。「根尾谷断層帯」が活動した典型的な内陸地殻内地震（いわゆる直下型地震）であり、これは記録が残っている日本の内陸...
            Read more